All Conference Baseball Team
2004
| Player | School | Year | Team |
| Bryce Crowley | Newburg | Sr. | Player of the Year |
| Craig Penley | Plato | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Caleb Rowden | Iberia | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Marshall MaCormic | Newburg | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Jay Goodrich | Crocker | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Thomas Vesely | Plato | Sr. | 1st Team |
| James Huff | Licking | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Seth Kimrey | Licking | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Danny Trusty | Iberia | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Kyle Thiltgen | Newburg | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Jimmy Mendenhall | Licking | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Brian Becker | Stoutland | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Jeff Creamer | Dixon | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Doug Robertson | Iberia | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Travis Thorpe | Newburg | Jr. | 1st Team |
| Kris Irwin | Plato | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Brad Lavely | Licking | Jr. | 1st Team |
| Shannon Hudson | Laquey | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Chad Luttrell | Iberia | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Ryan Bernard | Dixon | Jr. | 1st Team |
| Brian Schoffstall | Stoutland | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Jesse Wilson | Crocker | Jr. | 1st Team |
| Cory Kyle | Stoutland | Fr. | 1st Team |
| Max Lawson | Iberia | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Brian Strain | Richland | So. | 1st Team |
| Rob McNamara | Newburg | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Austin Johnson | Dixon | Sr. | Honorable Mention |
| Andrew Liley | Plato | Sr. | Honorable Mention |
| Jared Peterson | Laquey | Jr. | Honorable Mention |